About Steve Keen

I am Professor of Economics and Head of Economics, History and Politics at Kingston University London, and a long time critic of conventional economic thought. As well as attacking mainstream thought in Debunking Economics, I am also developing an alternative dynamic approach to economic modelling. The key issue I am tackling here is the prospect for a debt-deflation on the back of the enormous private debts accumulated globally, and our very low rate of inflation.

Steve Keen’s Debtwatch No. 33 April 2009: Lies, Damned Lies, and Housing Statistics

Flattr this!

Lies, damned lies, and sta­tis­tics” is part of a phrase attrib­uted to Ben­jamin Dis­raeli and pop­u­larised in the Unit­ed States by Mark Twain: “There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and sta­tis­tics.” The state­ment refers to the per­sua­sive pow­er of num­bers, the use of sta­tis­tics to bol­ster weak argu­ments, and the ten­den­cy of peo­ple to dis­par­age sta­tis­tics that do not sup­port their posi­tions. (Wikipedia)

Two recent speech­es by the RBA sup­port­ed the con­tention that Aus­tralian house prices are no longer over­val­ued, that mort­gage repay­ment costs have returned to his­toric aver­ages, that Aus­tralia is suf­fer­ing a hous­ing short­age, and there­fore that the Aus­tralian hous­ing mar­ket should not expe­ri­ence the cat­a­stroph­ic falls that are now com­mon­place across the OECD–and espe­cial­ly in the USA.

And you think I’m ornery (2)

Flattr this!

I’ve just been sent this link to a hilar­i­ous face-off between Max Keis­er and an Eco­nom­ics Pro­fes­sor. Max calls the Wall Street spec­u­la­tors “finan­cial ter­ror­ists”, calls for decap­i­ta­tion as in days of olde…

The most fun I got out of this was watch­ing the Pro­fes­sor’s dis­com­fort, and his attempts to under­stand the cri­sis in terms of neo­clas­si­cal eco­nom­ic the­o­ry: mar­kets  are ratio­nal  and mere­ly respond to pol­i­cy, bonus­es are fine, the cri­sis is all due to bad mon­e­tary pol­i­cy…

Osinski’s “Manhattan Project”

Flattr this!

There’s an inter­est­ing sto­ry in the New York Mag­a­zine by Michael Osin­s­ki–the author of the main soft­ware pack­age used to cre­ate the CMOs and CDOs that have helped crip­ple the finan­cial sys­tem.

Osin­ski’s sto­ry is worth a read in its own right. But what I found curi­ous about it was that he appears unaware of a flaw that exist­ed in those prod­ucts from the outset–the pre­sump­tion that the stan­dard math­e­mat­ics of risk and return could be applied to finan­cial assets. He does­n’t even men­tion this top­ic, but state­ments like the fol­low­ing imply that his soft­ware used a stan­dard prob­a­bil­i­ty dis­tri­b­u­tion to cal­cu­late risk and return for a giv­en bond:

Big Ideas: In place of a podcast

Flattr this!

I’m still hav­ing dif­fi­cul­ties get­ting my pod­casts up and run­ning at the moment, so in lieu here is a link to the ABC Radio Nation­al Big Ideas record­ing of an Evatt Foun­da­tion forum on the Glob­al Finan­cial Cri­sis.

Speak­ers were Bernie Fras­er, ex-Gov­er­nor of the Reserve Bank of Aus­tralia, myself, and Gar­ry Weiss, a cor­po­rate lawyer (this is also the speak­ing order).

Neoclassical Economics: mad, bad, and dangerous to know

Flattr this!

The whole of the most recent Real World Eco­nom­ics Review (for­mer­ly known as the Post-Autis­tic Eco­nom­ics Review) is devot­ed to the ques­tion of “How should the col­lapse of the world finan­cial sys­tem affect eco­nom­ics?”.

My paper, which led vol­ume 49, is repro­duced below. If you’d like to read the entire vol­ume, click here for the online ver­sion and here for the PDF. You can also go here for back issues, and to sub­scribe for free.

The most impor­tant thing that glob­al finan­cial cri­sis has done for eco­nom­ic the­o­ry is to show that neo­clas­si­cal eco­nom­ics is not mere­ly wrong, but dan­ger­ous.

Let 1001 Flowers Bloom…

Flattr this!

This is a face­tious way of let­ting you all know that, as of about 5 min­utes ago, there are now 1,000 users (plus yours tru­ly) sub­cribed to this blog.

The aver­age dai­ly unique read­er­ship count is cur­rent­ly 5,500, which I believe implies rough­ly 3–5 times that many read­ers on a month­ly basis.

I also know from feed­back from jour­nal­ists and oth­er cor­re­spon­dents that the com­ments made here are read and appre­ci­at­ed by a very wide audi­ence. My posts might be the ful­crum, but the con­tri­bu­tions from you all keep the wheels well and tru­ly spin­ning. I’ve also learnt a lot from what has been post­ed here.

FHB Boost is Australia’s “Sub-prime Lite”

Flattr this!

The First Home Own­ers Boost (as it is offi­cial­ly known) has cer­tain­ly giv­en the Gov­ern­ment bang for its buck. By spend­ing rough­ly $200 mil­lion of its own mon­ey to date, it has added about $3 bil­lion to the hous­ing mar­ket. But the addi­tion­al $2.8 bil­lion has come from increased mort­gage debt tak­en on by those most vul­ner­a­ble to a seri­ous eco­nom­ic down­turn, at a time when the lat­est “unex­pect­ed” increase in unem­ploy­ment indi­cates that, like it or not, the glob­al down­turn is com­ing our way.

James Galbraith: No Return to Normal

Flattr this!

James Gal­braith has writ­ten a very good analy­sis of the cri­sis and why the poli­cies being fol­lowed in the USA (and, by impli­ca­tion, here) will not work.

I repro­duce some extracts here to give you a flavour of the arti­cle, but I rec­om­mend a read of the full paper in the Wash­ing­ton Monthly–thanks to blog mem­ber War­ren Raft­shol for bring­ing it to my atten­tion. The empha­sis added to some points is mine.

It’s just a flesh wound…”

Flattr this!

It seems we’ve moved from Stan­ley Kubrick to John Cleese. Rory Robert­son’s reply to my “Rory Robert­son Designs a Car” post reminds me of one of my many favourite scenes from Mon­ty Python, the fight between King Arthur and the Black Knight:

King Arthur: [after Arthur’s cut off both of the Black Knight’s arms] Look, you stu­pid Bas­tard. You’ve got no arms left. 

Black Knight: Yes I have. 

King Arthur: *Look*! 

Black Knight: It’s just a flesh wound…

Rory Robertson Designs a Car

Flattr this!

A new high per­for­mance hybrid car has recent­ly been released by a Ror­ing Motors, Inc. Accord­ing to Man­ag­ing Direc­tor Rory Robert­son, the new “GoFlow­Mo­bile” ™© achieves unpar­al­leled per­for­mance for a hybrid car, by apply­ing a sim­ple insight from eco­nom­ics to the hide-bound world of engi­neer­ing.

Mr Robert­son, an econ­o­mist, took over the firm in a hos­tile pri­vate equi­ty bid, because he saw an oppor­tu­ni­ty to bring eco­nom­ic think­ing to bear on the vexed issue of design­ing the world’s fastest hybrid car.