Will the Soufflé rise twice? (3)

Flattr this!

My pre­vi­ous post on house price data from the BIS (How to spot a hous­ing bub­ble before it bursts, Octo­ber 15) scotched one part of the ‘No Bub­ble Dow­nun­der’ case: Aus­tralia is one of four coun­tries where house prices are more than twice as high as they were in real terms in 1985 (see Fig­ure 1).

Fig­ure 1: The Bub­ble Con­tenders

Graph for Housing hopes: Will the souffle rise twice?

There may be oth­ers too of course, since the BIS data doesn’t go back that far for many coun­tries (and as sev­er­al Twit­ter cor­re­spon­dents point­ed out, there’s some­thing suss about the Cana­di­an data that implied there is no Loonie Bub­ble ; I’ll fol­low up on that issue in a future post). On the BIS data (which stops in 2012), only Bel­gium still had ris­ing prices – though we all know that Australia’s and the UK’s prices are now on the rise again, the lat­ter thanks to the UK’s ‘Help to Sell’ pro­gram (the equiv­a­lent of Australia’s now large­ly defunct First Home Ven­dors Grant). But on the BIS data, Aus­tralia, The Nether­lands, Bel­gium and the UK (in increas­ing order) are arguably unburst hous­ing bub­bles.

Click here to read the rest of this post.

PS The Busi­ness Spec­ta­tor arti­cle acci­den­tal­ly drops my cor­re­la­tion tables–or maybe they were con­sid­ered too nerd-like. They are repro­duced below:

Coun­try Start End Years Cor­re­la­tion
USA

1977

2012

35.0

0.7

Spain

1989

2012

22.9

0.68

Nor­way

1993

2012

18.8

0.64

UK

1970

2012

42.5

0.58

Aus­tralia

1988

2012

24.3

0.56

Den­mark

1997

2012

15.0

0.51

Japan

1986

2012

25.8

0.48

Nether­lands

1993

2012

19.0

0.46

Swe­den

1987

2012

24.8

0.43

Cana­da

1982

2012

29.9

0.39

Bel­gium

1983

2012

29.0

0.2

Italy

1992

2012

20.5

0.13

Aus­tria

2001

2012

11.0

0.12

Ger­many

2001

2012

10.8

0.08

Por­tu­gal

1989

2012

22.9

0.02

And for coun­tries where there was less than 10 years’ data:

Coun­try Start End Years Cor­re­la­tion
Greece

2007

2012

4.8

0.61

Ire­land

2007

2012

4.8

0.49

France

2008

2012

4.5

0.95

Bookmark the permalink.

About Steve Keen

I am Professor of Economics and Head of Economics, History and Politics at Kingston University London, and a long time critic of conventional economic thought. As well as attacking mainstream thought in Debunking Economics, I am also developing an alternative dynamic approach to economic modelling. The key issue I am tackling here is the prospect for a debt-deflation on the back of the enormous private debts accumulated globally, and our very low rate of inflation.