China’s Concrete Bubble

Chinese construction keeps trending down with Sany the worlds sixth largest heavy machinery maker reporting a rise in profit of 5.4% in the same quarter as a blow out in receivables of USD $1.39 billion and cash reserves falling by USD $535 million . Sany is clearly booking profits on 100% financed machinery while providing zero transparency on credit risk and delinquency . If the GFC has taught the world anything. then 100% 'no money down" vendor finance should ring alarm bells. This all started about about 3 months ago when Zoomlion started to aggressively financing heavy machinery for anyone that wanted to sign up
An analyst told the International Finance News that Sany’s golden age of development has clearly passed. Recent news of staff cuts, changes to the wage structure and offering zero down payments are perhaps the company’s way of seeking a breakthrough during this challenging period, the analyst said.
After losing market share Sany responded by unlocking GPS disablement that are normally included in vendor finance deals and removing the 20% deposit requirement on new machinery .
As China slows, its construction equipment makers have been accelerating production – based on the simple idea that long-term survival can be ensured by getting big, fast. The amount of gear produced by the industry increased by almost 80 per cent between 2008 and last year, when 484,316 units were made, according to data from Bloomberg. This was 13,256 more units than the industry could sell – in spite of a near doubling in exports to more than 40,000 units.
Even worse, also according to Bloomberg: demand for such equipment in China dropped 56 per cent in the year to April.
Matthew Forney and Stella Zhou, writing in Draganomics’ China Economic Quarterly for June, look at Sany and its rivals. They note that industry executives are talking of a “collapse” and are looking to export their way out of trouble.
All of these companies are reacting to a substantial market slowdown by expanding their financing options. XCMG the 3rd largest heavy equipment maker in China sales soared by 44% in 2011 by introducing ‘no money down’ vendor finance , opening four new factories this week .
All of these companies are buying overseas manufacturers , XCMG is finalising a deal to invest in privately held German machinery manufacturer Schwing . Sany has just bought Putzmeister Holding GmbH for nearly $500 million . Meanwhile, Zoolion the company we mentioned in The Looting of China has investors increasingly concerned about the machinery manufacturer’s plan of raising huge bank loans of up to 140 billion yuan (US$22.2 billion) , this seems an extraordinary amount of debt to raise for as yet an unstated purpose. Zoomlion, Sany and XCMG (as well as 30 others are headquartered in Changsha, Hunan where by 2015 the city’s construction machinery products will account for almost a third of those sold globally, rising from its current 9 percent share. Whose Mayer Zhang Jianfei, a former director of highways at the Ministry of Transport and World Bank adviser on transportation, said that by the end of the 12th Five-Year Plan (2011–15), total sales in the city’s construction equipment sector will have hit 300 billion yuan ($47 billion) . who with that heavy machinery available built one of those ghost cities you keep hearing about (if you follow this Google map link you can explore the scale of these cities for yourself)
This is economic madness on a scale never before seen in history and it wont end well for anyone.


re:
RJ
July 6, 2012 at 7:39 am | #
Noel Kelly
July 6, 2012 at 12:52 am | #
.….…
Not true. More debt always means more savings. In part the huge increase in our non Govt debt liability is a result of our desire to save (requiring debt assets) and the refusal of Govt to play their part by running MUCH LARGER DEFICITS.
End Quote
The first two sentences are correct but it does not follow that governments must run much larger deficits — that is not desirable.
Governments should be enforcing regulations designed to limit the criminal activities of financial firms rather than being complicit in the criminal behavior. Also leave the insolvent component of these firms die rather than continuing to suck wealth from the rest of the economy.
In a saner investment environment there would be more people prepared to invest in businesses rather than save. The only sane investment options at present are in your own business and/or items that reduce your personal consumption such as solar panels, housing insulation, more economic motor vehicle, etc. These are investments where the return can be calculated rationally.
“Steve H., why take such a tortuous path when you can just accept things are they are and be content.”
Well, because then I’d actually be some kind of mystical mystic.…instead of just a Bodhisattva.
“In a saner investment environment there would be more people prepared to invest in businesses rather than save.”
Money when created by
DEBIT DEBT
CREDIT BANK CREDIT (MONEY)
Does not disappear. Rather it just moves from bank account to bank account
So money that follows the saving path rather than the consumption path will eventually find its way into investment assets
LIKE
Govt bonds
Shares
Property
etc
The problem today is NOT ENOUGH GOVT DEBT = too much non govt debt (as this sector has to try and make up the shortfall) and too little savings and money for consumption (unemployment) and investment.
And more Govt debt could be generated by say a large tax cut. Or higher pensions or benefits. Not just more govt spending (or waste).
Steve Hummel
July 6, 2012 at 4:21 pm | #
“Steve H., why take such a tortuous path when you can just accept things are they are and be content.”
You can not accept the world as it is. So you drift into impossible make believe (as many do).
For example you accept debt free money is not possible. But still want it.
Let us not forget that some countries are a Communist dictatorship, they run the country just like Stalin did/is, and they don’t need to fool people like in a democratic society. If you disagree they will silence you or worst send you to a re-education forced labour camp.
Can anyone really believe statistics, figures or anything from such oppression?In time this will end in an economic, cultural and humanitarian catastrophe, minimise your exposure, and only invest in yourself.
“So you drift into impossible make believe…”
No, it is you who are deluded because you still think that you can achieve Valhalla (or even begin to paddle in its direction in a “leaky old boat”).…WITHOUT SIMULTANEOUSLY FREEING THE INDIVIDUAL ALSO. That makes YOU the historically ignorant hopeless romantic.…not me.
Row on toward your delusional, scientistic dreams of “Santa Catalina, the island of romance.”
And it’s not what you call money, its the quality and inclusiveness of the intentions you mean to put it to, that is important.
Our Cultural Heritage of productive potential, the true, never diminishing and always expanding value and source from which debt/credit/money could be created.
Captured Government and private and Central Banks are complicit and corrupt entities whose moral, ethical and rational standing is puny by comparison.
The real problem we face is that people believe that machines are more powerful than understanding and wisdom. I do not wish to diminish the actuality or power of either. Just make a hypnotized world break free of the all powerful machines who have captured their consciousness and created a Matrix they mistake for actual reality.
re: RJ
.….…..
So money that follows the saving path rather than the consumption path will eventually find its way into investment assets
LIKE
Govt bonds
Shares
Property
etc
The problem today is NOT ENOUGH GOVT DEBT = too much non govt debt (as this sector has to try and make up the shortfall) and too little savings and money for consumption (unemployment) and investment.
And more Govt debt could be generated by say a large tax cut. Or higher pensions or benefits. Not just more govt spending (or waste).
End Quote
If you want to blame governments for problems then it is their inability to take action against the criminal activity in the financial sector, not the government’s lack of debt. Governments have continued to encourage the criminal activity by supporting insolvent firms to maintain business as usual — creating more government debt so the fat salaries and bonuses can continue to be paid.
Arguably the best way out is to let the insolvent firms fail rather than the government taking on more debt. This is the fastest way to eliminate debt that cannot be repaid. The longer the corrupt behaviors are supported by public funds the more entrenched they become. So governments do not necessarily need to take on more debt to solve the debt problem.
My word! The editing of this article, if it occurred at all, is horrible! It’s a shame that your reporting must lose such a great deal of credibility simply because it wasn’t proof read before posting.
David not wanting to correct your comment.… but you need a comma after because
@RJ
Think we’re using different meaning for ‘savers’, suspect mine is unorthodox. That being some who saves large deposits and plans for high interest rates at some point during the life of a loan. For them, current lending practices means assets values have been over priced for decades.
Ie Being told by a real estate agent the I should be paying 1000 times weekly rent for a house. I told him 750, 800 tops. I’m old enough to remember 17% home loan rates & 23%/24% rates for business loans, and the resultant failures.
Also your model looks to be too simple. That may be true in simple economy, without internal divisions (borrowing here funded by OS savers) and without modern banking (credit created against fractional reserves).
cc @RickW